Garage Floor Paint vs Epoxy
Craftsman Concrete Floors specializes in the installation of commercial-grade concrete coatings, including epoxy garage floors. These floors endure extreme conditions and require a long, uninterrupted service life. As one of the largest installers of specialized commercial concrete coatings in the nation, we have the expertise to provide coating systems that offer reliable, long-term concrete protection for builders and homeowners companies.
When planning a garage upgrade, choosing a garage floor installation that aligns with your budget, DIY skills, and durability needs is crucial. All installations should improve staining, ease of cleaning, and eliminate concrete dusting, though aesthetics can differ significantly. This article examines the pros and cons of big-box retail garage floor paint kits versus professional epoxy floors, along with the expected costs for each system.
Garage Floor Gallery
What are the Pros and Cons of Garage Floor Paints?
Garage concrete paint is similar to latex wall paints but is modified for better durability and adhesion. Regardless, these paints are made primarily using acrylic resins. In contrast, professional garage floor systems utilize a combination of more durable plastic resins, including epoxy and polyurethane, providing superior performance and longevity. This distinction is important for choosing the right flooring solution for your needs.
Pros of Garage Floor Paint
Garage floor epoxy paint typically combines latex acrylic paint with a small amount of epoxy, enhancing the paint’s adhesion to concrete and making the floor more durable than standard acrylic paint. This mix provides a stronger, longer-lasting finish ideal for garage areas.
Pros of Big-Box Retail Garage Floor Paint:
- Affordable: Cost-effective option, ideal for budget-friendly projects.
- Easily Accessible: Readily available at most large hardware stores.
- Low Odor: Minimal smell during application, making it comfortable to use.
- Simple Application: Designed for DIY projects, easy for non-professionals to apply.
- Low VOCs: Safer installation process.
- Customizable Colors Mixed In-Store: Offers a variety of color options that can be mixed on-site for personal preference.
- Suitable for Light Use: Ideal for floors not exposed to heavy vehicle traffic or harsh chemicals.
For more information about epoxy floor costs, visit our epoxy floor cost guide.
Cons of Garage Floor Paint
While big-box retail paint is an easy way to improve the look of a garage floor, it may require upkeep, which can be a drawback. Painted floors often need touchups to reach their full expected lifespan, and at times, they may even begin to deteriorate shortly after installation. At Craftsman Concrete, we’ve seen these systems fail as soon as a few days after installation, due to insufficient surface prep.
Cons of Epoxy Garage Floor Paint:
- Insufficient Surface Prep: Proper concrete preparation, like shot-blasting, is essential for good adhesion–equipment not accessible to DIY installers.
- DIY Competence Required: Some skills are required for proper application.
- Thin System Thickness: Applied layer is relatively thin, creating delamination and scratching issues.
- Prone to Hot Tire Pickup: Most systems will peel overtime when exposed to hot tires.
- Limited Chemical Resistance: Not suitable for harsh chemical exposure or even exposure to some vehicle fluids
- Matte Finish: Less glossy appearance than professional floors creates a distinctly look DIY.
- Low Solids Content: Material quality is far lower than professionally installed 100% solids systems.
Want to Learn More About Epoxy Floors?
We’re here to guide you through the design of our products. A Concrete Floor Specialist will reach out within one business day.
What are the Pros and Cons of Garage Floor Epoxy Coatings?
Pros of Epoxy Coating
For many of our customers, the primary goal of garage floor finishing is to create an easy-to-clean floor. Others seek a high-end finish for its bold aesthetics and endless color options. Finally, some use their garages for purposes like fitness or woodworking. Regardless of your specific needs, Craftsman Concrete Floors offers a specialized, American-made epoxy solution. Below are the pros of our epoxy systems.
Pros of Garage Floor Epoxy Coatings:
- Durable: Designed to withstand heavy abrasive wear, frequent impact, and daily vehicle traffic.
- Chemical Resistance: Resists damage from vehicle fluids, cleaners, and most acids/bases.
- Customizable Finish: Craftsman Concrete offers an endless selection of colors, and finishes.
- Glossy Appearance: Reflective, bold, clean appearance.
- Long-Lasting: Proper installation can last up to 10 to 15 years.
- Dust-Free: Prevents concrete dusting.
- Re-coatable: Can be re-top-coated if the surface becomes worn.
- Easy to Clean: Simple to maintain with a wet mop or even a pressure washer.
For more info, visit our ‘benefits of epoxy garage floors‘ page
Cons of Epoxy Coatings
While we highly recommend our professional epoxy system, there are some compromises to consider before making your decision. Understanding the potential drawbacks will help you make an informed choice about whether our system is the right fit for your garage project. Here is a detailed look at the cons of our epoxy system
Cons of Garage Floor Epoxy Coatings:
- Professional Installation Required: Needs skilled professional and specialized equipment for proper application.
- Expensive: Higher upfront costs compared to concrete paint.
- Material Intensive: Requires a significant amount of material for installation.
- Time-Consuming: Installation process generally takes about three days.
- Susceptible to Heat Damage: Welding and other very high-heat sources can harm the surface.
- UV Stability Issues: Some materials may yellow over time from frequent, prolonged sun exposure. For systems installed in these conditions, some modifications will be made to prevent yellowing.
Epoxy Services We Offer
Our Clients
How much Do Garage Floor Systems Cost
Garage Floor Paint CosT
| Price Range | Description | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Garage Floor Paint Kit | $190 – $310 | 2 Part Garage Floor Paint Kit | Lowes, Home Depot, etc. |
| Pressure Washer Rental | $70 – $100 | 3000 PSI or Higher | Degreaser may be applied prior to pressure washing. |
| Labor | DIY | 2-3 Days | Time depends on system and concrete prep method. |
| Total | $260 – $410 | Plus Labor |
Garage Floor Epoxy Cost
| Cost Component | Price Range | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Labor Costs | $5 – $9 per sq. ft. | Varies based on size and complexity of the job |
| Material Costs | $2 – $6 per sq. ft. | Influenced by material quality and number of coats needed |
| Standard Two-Car Garage Size | $4,000 – $7,000 | Total for 380 – 450 sq. ft. garage |
Polished Concrete may also be installed in garages. Visit our ‘polished concrete vs epoxy garage floor‘ page for more info.
Hear What Our Customers Say About our Floors
Blog
Project Highlight: New Residential Terrazzo Floors in Fort Worth, Texas
Project Highlight: 67,000 Sq. Ft. ESD Epoxy in Houston, Texas
